| Tex Schramm Award(Exec.) | 2001: Dan Wever, Rynos 2002: Chris Porsch, Stallions 2003: Joe Semro, Wolfpack 2004: Al Smith, Warriors |
| Coach of the Year | 2001: Captain Morgan, Outlaws 2002: Noodles Scanlan, Tattoo Crew 2003: Mike Ditka, Rynos 2004: George Halas, Warriors |
| Rookie of the Year | 2001: RB LaDainian Tomlinson, Tattoo Crew 2002: Clinton Portis, Dirty Dozen 2003: WR Andre Johnson, Jorsemen 2004: WR Michael Clayton, Wildfire |
| M.V.P. Award | 2001: RB Marshall Faulk, Charity's Chumps 2002: RB Priest Holmes, Rynos 2003: WR Randy Moss, Roscoes 2004: QB Peyton Manning, Roscoes |
| Johnny Unitas Award(Player of the Year) | 2001: QB Jeff Garcia, Rynos 2002: RB Priest Holmes, Rynos 2003: RB Ahman Green, Wolfpack 2004: QB Peyton Manning, Roscoes |